17 
N°III 2024   MuseoMag 
NEW ACQUISITION 
unmistakably assert her identity as an artist, inde- 
pendent woman and expecting mother. In doing so, 
the photo challenges the conventional norms of the 
era and the passive role largely assigned to women, 
especially pregnant women. The self-portrait, thus, 
becomes an important expression of the artist’s 
autonomy and creative self-determination and 
prompts us to question traditional notions of femini- 
nity, motherhood and creative agency. 
SOCIAL CONTEXT 
The social context of the 1940s, marked by traditio- 
nal gender roles and limited opportunities for wo- 
men in the arts, provides a backdrop against which 
Diane Arbus’s self-portrait gains additional impor- 
tance. Within this context, her self-portrait does not 
only defy societal expectations of what an artist and 
a mother should be, but also reframes the discourse 
around maternal representation in art, a subject that 
was, at the time, not depicted in such a direct and 
unidealised manner. 
Arbus is primarily recognised for her portraits of 
marginalised individuals and communities, offering 
insights into their unique experiences and challen- 
ges. Despite her acclaim, Arbus was a controversial 
figure who often faced criticism, with renowned art 
critic Susan Sontag, for instance, arguing that her 
photos were taken from a privileged position that 
emphasises her subjects’ “otherness”. In this photo, 
Arbus herself embodies the “other”, confronting 
existing biases and stereotypical ideas of an artist 
and a mother in the 1940s head-on, with an honest 
and direct gaze. 
From the 1960s onwards, with the rise of second- 
wave feminism, female artists have gradually deve- 
loped their own identity models, highlighted by art 
historian Linda Nochlin’s seminal question in 1971: 
“Why have there been no great women artists?”. 
Despite the progress made by women artists at that 
time, however, the themes of birth and motherhood 
still remained somewhat of a taboo. For centuries, 
references to women’s reproductive capacity were 
used to dismiss their suitability for higher cultural 
achievements, serving as an argument for their sup- 
pression and exclusion. In this context, it’s hardly 
surprising that feminist artists of the time initially fo- 
cused on female emancipation, which was in most 
cases aligned with being childless. Consequently, 
the idea that women must choose between being 
great artists and being mothers persist to this day. 
This social context reveals the ongoing challenges 
faced by women artists who navigate art and 
motherhood in a world that (still) often fails to 
accommodate both simultaneously. 
MOTHERHOOD 
Motherhood has long been a theme in art throughout 
history. In European art history, it has often been 
portrayed in a highly idealised and sacred way, 
as a symbol of fertility, caregiving and nurturing, 
exemplified by the Virgin Mary and child. In these 
visual representations, mothers seem to be de- 
picted as embodiments of purity, protection, ten- 
derness and devotion. Over the centuries, views 
on motherhood in art have evolved, illustrated by 
women artist like Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun, who 
painted herself with her daughter. More recently, 
artists such as Frida Kahlo or Louise Bourgeois have 
critically reevaluated and enriched the discourse 
on maternal experience, incorporating deeply 
personal, thought-provoking and complex elements 
of motherhood into their works. 
Today, the subject of art and motherhood seems 
to be gaining increased visibility in the art world, 
with major exhibitions such as the UK traveling show 
Arts of Creation: On Art and Motherhood, curated 
by Hettie Judah, author of the book How to Not 
Exclude Artist Mothers (and other parents), setting 
the example. In Luxembourg’s art scene, too, contem- 
porary artists have actively explored the subject 
of maternity. The uproar surrounding a pregnant 
Gëlle Fra in 2001, when feminist artist Sanja Iveković 
presented her work Lady Rosa of Luxembourg for 
the first time, is a compelling example of the ongoing 
debates and controversies related to various issues, 
including, but not limited to, the representation of the 
pregnant female body. 
The dual role of being a mother and an artist has 
also been investigated by Luxembourgish artists. 
Sarah Schleich, for example, titled a recent exhibition 
in Dudelange after her daughter’s birth time, using 
it as a lens to examine identity formation. Likewise, 
Krystyna Dul frequently documents her own expe- 
riences of motherhood through photography and 
Germaine Hoffmann, a collage artist, provides a 
compelling personal perspective. The latter had her 
first monographic show at a Luxembourgish institu- 
tion at the age of 90. Being a mother first, before 
dedicating herself to her art, her story sheds light on 
the challenges of juggling a creative career with the 
responsibilities of being a mother. 
Lis Hausemer